Wednesday, October 28, 2009

US power and shift

The authors note that the US dominates ICTs and has much influence over international policy and governance. However, they predict that by 2025, the US will not longer be in the leadership position due to various factors, including the emerge of China in the world markets. Chinese engineers, Chinese firms and global leaders are evidence that China is assuming a global leadership position. The US is currently the leader because it has the largest investment base, is the leader in software and will remain in the top 3 global markets across all types of ICT markets. The US is also the leading producer of value-added content (entertainment).

They state that power is the influence and an ability to set an agenda, but it does not explain the why or what countries see. “Power does not explain what the powerful seek—multilateral cooperation or a coercive empire, for example. Neither does power explain the organization of decision making and action (market governance) shapes how preferences and influence are transformed into decisions.” The authors say that the decision process itself affects outcomes. If the US has indispensiable power, how will this change not only their power and influence, but the roles that other nations play?

The authors state a third shift in global governance is under way and that the time is ripe to confront significant internal changes, reorganize domestic governance and restructure global governance in various powerful markets. They write that we cannot assume each technology calls for a specific set of laws or regulations, but the success of tech type can lead to subsequent governance decisions.

So, as more innovations proliferate will their be yet another type of governance needed? I assume that regulations will continually be changing, not only because of the emergence of new technologies and new actors, but also because of the different interests by nations, individuals and organizations. The process will change, but the needs will most likely stay similar. It will only get more complicated because of innovations and the array of actors. I don't know if the US will falter in in its leadership role by 2020, but it does seem that they will no longer be the only ones dominating. It will be interested to see if China does take a more prominent leadership position or if another country steps up and somehow becomes influential.


Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Does Facebook Own Me?

While I'm not much for technical jargon or political economy, I thought Cowhey and Aronson did bring up a good question at the end of Chapter 5. "Who owns the Information?" In this world where so many people have personal information on Myspace or Facebook who does that information belong to? Does it belong to the individual? Does it belong to the site owners because the person freely gave them the information? Or is it somewhere in between? Do we forfeit our ownership of that information by making it public (I would say no, but I'm sure many others would say yes).
I recall a few months back an uproar over a proposed change to Facebook regulations which would allow them to use personal information, including people's uploaded photos in basically any manner they wanted. Facebook backed down on the changes after the users angrily protested. I was not pleased with what Facebook wanted to do, but did we all have a right to object? Anything we put on Facebook's site we willing shared with them and many other people. Once we've done that who does that information belong to and who can use it? If one of my friends, or even someone posts a picture, I can copy it and keep it for myself as well, is that legitimate? Do I now have some sort of ownership to that photo?
Personally I would like to think that like Intellectual Property Rights personal information about myself remains under my "ownership" even if I have put it on Facebook. If I freely give my credit card number to purchase something online, that site doesn't own that information and can't sell it (although I suppose if I posted it publicly I'm not sure what type of recourse I would have if someone used it). However I have heard of issues with this already in cases of people not being allowed to see their own credit reports or medical records, for whatever reason. What can we do to keep our personal information under our control in an age when more and more personal data is being displayed for the world? Would we have to stop using things like Facebook or MySpace to safeguard our information from being commodified or is there another way?

Long Sentences, Few New Concepts

Cowey and Aronson start out with an exciting teaser in Ch 1:
"Many assume--wrongly, we think-- that if governments stand aside, the technology will sweep away all obstacles and bring widespread worldwide prosperity. Others assume the real challenge is to get governments out of the pockets of large corporations and to unleash digitally enabled 'people power.' (Benkler, Castells, etc., right?)....these views are mistaken."

Well, alright, I thought, something new! But I don't feel like they ever dove into why those views are mistaken. Or perhaps the way they address it is by saying "ahhh, but it's more complex than one or the other..it's BOTH! shocker!", and then repeatedly stating the obvious. Some of my favorites were:

"Marketplace reforms at home demand complementary actions at the domestic level" (Ch 1, p 13)

"global governance is deeply entangled with power and politics." (Ch 1, p13 )

"responsible governments begin by seeking ways to improve their public and national interests...Powerful markets get more of what they seek than weaker ones. (Ch1, p 14)

Because significant players in individual markets are influenced by their respective politics, when they come together to pursue global interests, the political aspects of their solutions predominate. (me paraphrasing from ch 6)

"Global market governance...is important because choices about the design of market
governance influence the winners and losers and the innovation and efficiency in the global ICT market" (Ch 6)

Whether an international institution that is responsible for the administration of a marketplace is a formal or informal (NGO) organization influences that marketplace. (paraphrasing Ch 6)

The one original assertion they did make and attempt to support was that the U.S. will be the "single largest influence on the global policy agenda" and the "pivot" on which the "Inflection Point" will turn until about 2025. They say the U.S
-has a lead in deployed ICT stock (examples would have helped, so I just take them at their word)
-has the largest investment base in the right areas for innovation
-is a leader in software and will remain so
-will remain in the 'top 3' global markets across all types of ICT markets
-is leading producer of value-added content (entertainment) This is questionable, but they do address it later and reference how long-tail markets and new markets like gaming can make that untrue very quickly. (p 107)

They also say China is not that big of a contender, the decline in U.S spending in ICT is overblown, and have a great discussion of net neutrality that makes me feel silly for saying that they have nothing to say. Clearly they do, and it's about net neutrality. And hwo global governance is important.

Right?



Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Isn't Media a Commodity?

Benkler and Castells only briefly touch on something we have also briefly discussed in class, the topic of p2p sharing, especially in terms of (free) music, movie, and TV downloads. While I'm human and of course want something free if I can get it, the trend of free file sharing and pirated movies, music, software, etc. does bother me. I suppose it is a human trait to want to keep your money and not spend it if you don't have to. After all you worked hard for that money, so if you can avoid spending it on movies, music, etc. shouldn't you?
However, someone else worked hard to produce that media so why do we believe they should just give it away for free? We wouldn't expect a loaf of bread or a gallon of milk for free just because we don't want to have to pay for it. Now there are the arguments that recording companies and studios make so much money off of their products, which it is implied, is undeserved (and I'm not getting into the unfair payment distributions, that's a whole other issue), so why does it matter if we download it for free? But does anyone really think if all media was either produced by small independent labels/companies, who didn't take big profits, or even self-produced it that there wouldn't be such a proliferation of p2p sharing? I seriously doubt it. This system could also make it harder for the small upstart media companies because people have gotten used to not paying for their media and won't want to start just because its a small company trying to get off the ground and make a profit.
We've seen this trend with newspapers too. People don't want to pay for online subscriptions (full disclaimer, I'm totally guilty of this too) and so the companies have to turn to the dwindling ad revenues to keep their sites and sometimes the entire paper afloat.
People still get annoyed if they have to wait through commercials for free online content, as we've discussed in class. However, someone has to pay for the work to be done. If no one pays musicians, writers, actors, directors to produce the media, they're going to find another job that will pay them and our media supply will decline. They might continue to produce media on the side because they like it, but it won't be of the same quantity and quality as if they could produce it for a full-time job.
While there are many issues involved in this discussion, to me, one of the main points it boils down to, is why do we think its ok to not pay media producers for their time, effort, and products? Isn't it a commodity just like everything else we pay for?

Monday, October 19, 2009

New Media, Politics and Regulation

Castell's article, “Communication, Power and Counter-power in the Network Society” introduces concepts that revolve around politics and decision-making in the network society. He writes about how politicians are the face of politics in general. They have to sell themselves using their and image and looks. This is particularly interesting given the time that article was written (2007) because communication technologies were decisive in the last presidential election. Blogs, emails, facebook and other such social media sites were all utilized by the candidates. This perhaps led to the high young adult turnout. Castells writes how credibility and destruction of credibility and character assassination become potent political weapons. This has also been the case recently with politicians personal lives showing up in the news. It is not just about the politics, but about the person. Trust plays a big part. The media can built politicians up or bring them down.

People have built what Castells calls mass self-communication via podcasts, wikis, blogs, SMS, and P2P sharing networks. 52% of bloggers say that they blog mostly for themselves. These kinds of mediums allow for a larger diversity of information that are of “largely autonomous origin.” This begs the question of credibility and reliability that we have been discussing in class. If people are purportedly writing blogs for themselves, than can we believe what they are saying? Should we even bother reading if it is mostly for themselves? Even those who write for an audience, there is an increasingly problematic dimension that the social media technologies have bring. Plurality and diversity of sources and information are very often seen as a positive, good thing because they afford consumers a greater amount of choice. However, there is also those who think it simply too much. We are inundated by information via the internet. Slander, false information, gimmicks included. Celebrities, for example, have been sued over what they report on twitter. Courtney Love said something negative about a brand and they are suing her. Not only that, but there are hackers who have gotten ahold of Demi Moore's account and posted some rather strange tweets. I'm not sure how to control hackers or check the majority of news posts for legitimacy, but this an important aspect that has recently been taken into consideration.

Castells contends that there is a “new media reality whose contours and effects will ultimately be decided through a series of political and business power struggles.” This made me think of an article I read yesterday about the White House and Fox. The media, as we have discussed and as Castells writes about, has the power to change people's minds and affect the decisions they make. The White House and Fox News are now in a battle. The NY Times article notes that the fight for 'truth' is not easy. The White House can't have a 'truth-o-meter' or a 'reality check.' So, the author of the article says that perhaps it is time to restore some imperiousness to the relationship. I don't think this is the best idea, but I'm not sure what either party can do.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/18/weekinreview/18davidcarr.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=obama%20fox&st=cse

Sunday, October 18, 2009

"The empires of the future are the empires of the mind"

--Manuel Caste--I mean, Winston Churchill. ;)

I also considered naming this post "Stealing my Thunder" but it's kind of ridiculous to imagine my thunder is even worthy of being stolen by Manuel Castells. Basically, reading Castells was really deflating because it was like reading the article that I have always dreamed of writing, but clearly never had the foresight or intelligence to write. In "Communication, Power and Counter-power in the Network Society," Castells touches on everything that I feel like I talk about with anyone who will listen obligingly, and then he actually managed to ground all of it it in this amazing body of research and theory while still keeping it accessible, relevant and free of jargon. He even cited danah boyd!

Moving past my jealousy, awe and hero worship (he's been knighted by 5 different governments, people), I will attempt to look at the article with a more critical eye. While I fully agree with Castells about the direct link between "...media and politics, the politics of scandal, and the crisis of political legitimacy in a global perspective," and I like his discussion of 'mass self-communication,' I was at first taken aback when he argued that "the media have become the social space where power is decided," though I would very much like for that to be the case (Castells, 2007). If nuclear and biological weapons didn't exist, sure, maybe we could say that, but until that sort of physical power isn't a concern anymore, isn't soft power still just soft power?

From what I can tell, many would now argue that weapons like that really are irrelevant now, at least in terms of wars between nations, but what about the horizontal networks formed through social media technology? Those networks are comprised of citizen media mavens and masses of people self-communicating and picking and choosing what they read, sure, but I wish that Castells had included a discussion of how trans-national terrorist organizations wield power in these networks as well. I suppose they would naturally be included as actors in the battle for the mind he outlines?

Daya Thussu concludes in Mapping Media Flow and Contra-Flow that "one should not lose sight of the fact that 'soft' media power is firmly underpinned by 'hard' political and economic power," and while she may be right, she may not be taking into account the 'hard' political power Castells shows to be in the hands of those in the 'horizontal networks' who can and do question the narratives put out by those with the 'hard' political and economic power (Thussu, 2006)...that power sometimes subverts, questions or even overrides the hard power of institutions like government and TNCs.





Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Karim Karim and tribalism

I don't know why the Karim Karim reading in particular got me on this train of thought-- there are surely hundreds of scholars who have asserted something along the lines of:

"the roots of the contemporary global system of nation states are to be found in colonialism," as he does in "Chapter 24: Reviewing the 'National' in International communication."

But all I can think as I read that sentence is "ok, sure, but can't you replace 'colonialism' with 'tribalism'?" Groups of human beings have been banding together and fighting each other for territory, resources and power pretty much since we started hunting and gathering, right? Even when tribes lived in peace it was because they respected certain tribal boundaries and codes of conduct. Furthermore, each tribe had oral histories and myths about themselves and their enemies that they passed on to "create their reality through communication," just as we tell ourselves stories about good guys and bad guys over and over and over again through film, journalism, TV, and now the interwebs. Yes, modern technology certainly made it possible for that to occur on a larger scale, but I can't see what has really changed except the size of groups and the scope and scale of their influence.